Welcome to Nugget Bridge - Premier Competitive Pokémon VGC Community

Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.

  • entries
  • comment
  • views

How Disconnections Affect WiFi Tournaments and Why That Matters

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0


blog-disconnectionsandwhytheymatter2.pngAnother season has passed us by and with it another announced plans to hold even more tournaments of the Global Battle Union just like the Friendlies but for actual stakes: Byes in Regionals. TPCi is right to raise the stakes for participation in these events as it increases competition and makes for a more enjoyable tournament for everyone involved (because who really wants to grind through tens of in-game teams?). However, TPCi must address the flaws built into the GBU format before hosting WiFi Tournaments for more than bragging rights: chief amongst those flaws are disconnections.

Disconnections are disruptive to the tournament process and violate good WiFi etiquette, a fact TPCi has acknowledged. In attempting to lessen the impact of disconnections on the 2012 Autumn Friendly, TPCi came up with a formula to identify those who are disconnecting more than the average. To wit, TPCi's formula looks like this:

(Disconnections) / (Wins + Losses + Disconnections) = Disconnection Rate

For players with a Rating of 1600 or higher:

Excluded from the Rankings if their Disconnection Rate is at least 10 points higher than the overall average across all players.

For players with a Rating of 1599 or lower:

Excluded from the Rankings if their Disconnection Rate is at least 20 points higher than the overall average across all players.

It's a start. Tying the disqualifying rate to the average is particularly clever as it shows that TPCi recognizes the major complaint of competitors: both parties are faulted when one party disconnects. Ignoring the fact that Game Freak apparently doesn't have access to the same technology the original Netbattle did and is unable to pinpoint which party disconnected, tying the disconnect rate to the average is the best short term fix for a long term problem.

However, there are still problems with this: it allows disconnections at all. Under this system, disconnections become a part of the game and managing your disconnection rate becomes more important than the actual Pokémon being played. Okay, that's a bit of an exaggeration, but the point remains: with current disconnection rules, avoiding battles can sometimes be as important as finishing them. Instead of finishing out every battle, like you would be forced to at any VGC event, you now have the option to disconnect and avoid the loss at the risk of increasing your disconnection rate above the average. In practice, assuming that a player plays 100 matches over the course of the tournament (a not unreasonable number if you desire top placement) and you match the average disconnection rate, you have 10 free losses that you can essentially drop. While not a factor at lower rankings, upon hitting the higher 1800s on into the 1900s and 2000s, any loss is potentially disastrous to your final ranking. If you have losses to spare, you're going to disconnect to protect your rating and your shot at the prizes. What this means is that players who place at the top of the bracket aren't necessarily the strongest Pokémon battler, though reaching that high a rank does require some Pokémon ability, but instead the players who were smartest about managing their disconnects and protecting their ranking.

Disconnections don't only affect the competitive side of the WiFi Tournaments, though. For those of us who are less concerned about our standings on the leadership and more concerned about playing some solid Pokémon, win or lose, disconnections sap all of the fun out of these tournaments for even the casual player. Using the data from our (admittedly small) sample of players final standings and records on the forums, the average disconnection rate is around 21% after excluding the highest and lowest disconnection rate. That's one out of every five battles that doesn't complete. While you can interpret a disconnection as a forfeit, the fact is that Pokémon is a game where anything can happen on any given turn and players looking to learn how to maintain their advantage and not give any ground will find themselves out of luck one out of every five times as they look to the GBU for practice. In terms of sheer "fun," there is nothing enjoyable about being disconnected on in the middle of the battle.

Pokémon Black and White 2 have been billed as introducing new, anti-disconnecting features for the GBU. While reports indicate that B/W 2 have introduced a feature that makes people who disconnect wait an hour before they can find a new battle, there are other reports that suggest that the major flaws of the original Black and White GBU remain, most importantly that B/W 2 still cannot tell who disconnected and who was disconnected on. This would actually make the problem even worse for players whose opponents disconnect. In this case, not only would they be taking a hit to their disconnection rate, but they'd also be booted from participating in the tournament for a whole hour through no fault of their own. What's more, this discouraging factor isn't reported to apply when the connection is lost, either because internet connection is spotty or your opponent has killed his internet, but only when your opponent actually shuts down and restarts his DS during the battle, leaving us back on square one.

Still, I'm optimistic about the next round of GBU tournaments to be played on Pokémon Black and White 2. Even assuming the worst, waiting an hour in between matches is a strong discouraging factor for those who play more casually and who won't want to go through the trouble of restarting their router, drastically reducing the average disconnection rate. Ideally, this will mean that players who maliciously disconnect from battles will be easier to catch and reduce the amount of disconnections available to players before they are disqualified, both of which heighten the competition and make the results more legitimate.

Ultimately, if TPCi wants to begin giving out Regionals Byes and potentially Championship Points for WiFi tournaments, they are going to need to address disconnections much more diligently than they currently have. While there are reasons for optimism and TPCi has made baby steps towards addressing the issue of disconnections, the problem is not solved, and fixing that problem only becomes more urgent as TPCi increases the stakes for WiFi tournaments by adding real prizes beyond bragging rights. Until Game Freak is able to upgrade their WiFi capabilities with the ability to detect who has disconnected, however, this is probably about as close to legitimate as TPCi can make the tournaments. TPCi has shown a willingness to learn from past mistakes with the guidance of the community, which makes me hopeful that each WiFi tournament will run more smoothly than the one before. While prizes for WiFi tournaments are perhaps coming a bit too soon, maybe that was the impetus needed to make the community care about the tournaments so we could make them better. Either way, I look forward to a new VGC season both in person and on WiFi.

Do you have thoughts about disconnections in the 2012 Autumn Friendly and their impact on WiFi tournaments as a whole? Let us know what you think in the comments section below.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

1 Comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Duy
      As a way to continually improve the quality of Regionals coverage via grassroots streaming, I'm going to start a feedback thread to see where the stream teams can continue to improve on to enhance the viewing experience for the viewers at home. Please keep the discussion as constructive as possible; people work hard and sacrifice a lot of their time for free labor on these streams. I will continue to add streams (feel free to remind me to add them as well) as they happen to this thread and hopefully we can see continuous improvement throughout the season. For now, we can keep the feedback focused on commentary and the production values of each stream. If anything else comes to mind, feel free to add it, but try to refrain on leaving feedback on things that are out of the control of the stream teams and more related to how the tournament is run.
      Phoenix Regional Championships - October 1-2, 2016
      Commentators: Gabby Snyder and Jason Krell
      Producers: Gabby Snyder and Jason Krell
      Orlando Regional Championships - October 15-16, 2016
      Day 1
      Day 2
      Commentators: Gabby Snyder and Adam Dorricott
      Producer: TJ Digiacomo
    • By spookees
      2016-2017 Arizona TCG & VG Regional Championships
      October 1st and 2nd
      Saturday October 1st
      Main event: VG Regional Championships
      Where: Phoenix Convention Center (South Building), 100 N 3rd St. Phoenix, AZ 85004 www.phoenixconventioncenter.com
      VG: Registration starts: 8am Registration ends: 9am
      VG Please note: Players must load their Pokémon team with their items attached in the battle box. Team sheets are not needed.
      Players must bring their own system in the Nintendo 3DS family (any 2DS or 3DS system).
      Players must bring their own ORAS Game Card or downloadable version.
      Players must bring their own charger for their DS. Players are responsible for making sure their DS is charged for the event.
      · PLEASE NOTE: ALL players must be in the registration line NO LATER THAN THE END of the Registration time listed above. If you arrive later or get in line later than this time, you may receive a first round loss or denied entry to the event. Don't be late!
      ALL TCG & VG Players meeting: 9:30am ish
      Cost for ALL players (TCG & VG):
      Online Registration: $30.00 ( online closes on Wednesday Sept. 28, 2016)
      Onsite Registration: $40.00 cash/$41.00 credit card
      You can also pay in Bulk Pokémon Cards * (see below)
      ***Pokeparent Discount*** -Parents who are playing in the event and have at least one child playing in any age division will receive a $5 discount applied to their own entry fee. (This will be refunded during the event).
      VG Online registration: https://www.1playerplace.com/signups?event=H3YB54WQXY93PGK
      (Online Registration closes on Wednesday Sept. 28, 2016) After this date you have Onsite registration available.
      Juniors - Born 2006 or later
      Seniors - Born 2002, 2003, 2004 or 2005
      Masters - Born in 2001 and earlier
      All players in every age division will receive:
      ~~ Play Points (TBD) for participating.
      ~~ 1 Regional Promo Card, while supplies last.
      ~~ 1 Saturday Raffle Ticket
      ALL Players who REGISTER ONLINE will receive the following (while supplies last):
      ----VG Players----
      1 Pokémon Hat (Zygarde, Articuno, Moltres, Zapdos - Randomly distributed)
      1 AZ Regional Championships Stylus Pen
      1 AZ Wristband
      1 extra Raffle ticket
      REMEMBER: when you register online you MUST return and PRINT out your barcoded Form at the same time you register.
      READ THIS IS IMPORTANT: The registration page will take you to Paypal (you can use paypal or a credit/debit card for payment)- after payment is made you will be taken back to the original registration page to print out the barcoded entry form, if it does not take you back there, please go back to the link above and log in AGAIN, there will now be a REPRINT button, once you click on it, the entry form will appear.
      DO NOT WAIT and do it at a later time. I will not see you are registered and you will not get the dice or an extra raffle ticket. If you have any problems, please email me! FORGET to bring the print out to the event? You will be able to have one printed out for you at the door for an additional $5.00. You cannot play without it.
      * Bulk Pokémon Cards for Entry fee: 1300 Pokémon Cards will be equivalent to the Entry Fee ONSITE. They can be any MINT Pokémon cards excluding Basic Energy and Promo Cards. For those players who attend any LC/PC in September in Arizona, you may bring your cards to the event and I can register you ONLINE for Regionals (only 1000 cards are needed), so you too may get the special Regional Dice and a much faster line on the day of the event! You cannot use cards to cover the cost of the VIP experience.
      VIP Experience – Gold & Platinum Level (optional) – Available to ALL registered players in any age division (While supplies last!) You will have the option to purchase the VIP experience when you register using the link above for TCG or VG. It is the only way to get the VIP experience. This means no arriving extra early to the event, you will have a special VIP line (8am -9am). Don’t wait till the last minute, these will most likely sell out! Limited Quantities! No refunds.
      Gold Level
      VIP Lounge area access (minors + 1parent/guardian)
      VIP Reserved static seating for Swiss rounds
      AZ Regionals Messenger Bag (limited quantities)
      $10 lunch voucher (valid inside the main event hall)
      $10 Vendor voucher
      Pokémon Side event playmat
      VG players can choose their Entry Hat
      Wake up call on Day 2 if you make Top cut
      2 Dedicated Staff in Lounge
      Water & Snacks
      Cost: $90.00 + $30 Entry fee
      Platinum Level (very limited quantities)
      VIP Lounge area access (minors + 1 parent/guardian)
      VIP Reserved static seating for Swiss rounds
      AZ Regionals Messenger Bag
      $10 lunch voucher (valid inside the main event hall)
      $10 Vendor voucher
      Pokémon Side event playmat
      VG players can choose their Entry Hat
      Wake up call on Day 2 if you make Top cut
      2 Dedicated Staff in Lounge
      Water & Snacks
      + Sealed Booster box of STEAM SIEGE
      + Japanese Pokémon Sleeves (62-64 in pack)
      Cost: $140.00 + $30 Entry fee
      MASTERS there will be no Lunch break on Saturday/Sunday. Please plan accordingly. Seniors and Juniors will have a lunch break. This year there will be a Food Vendor inside our Main Hall. I would also highly recommend everyone bringing their own lunch bag. Last year the food locations around our event were crowded and had long lines. This year the Diamondbacks have a home game (both days), so it may be extremely crowded at any Food venue. Last year we had over 226 Masters, I do not want to run the risk of the Master division playing late into the night. My goal is to complete Day 1 Masters between 7pm-8pm at the latest. This of course is dependent on attendance and how long the rounds last.
      VG Tournament Details:
      Day 1:
      VG Tournament Rules & Formats Link for more details: http://www.pokemon.com/…/a…/tournaments-rules-and-resources/
      · Each age group will use Swiss rounds- this means all players get to play every round even if they lose every game. The number of Swiss rounds will be determined by the amount of players in each division. Swiss Rounds - Best 2 of 3.
      --->Top Cut: Will be played on Day 2
       Top Cut matches are Best of 3
       Top Cut is Single Elimination
       Swiss Rounds are Best of 1
      8 Players: 3 Swiss Rounds, Top 2 Cut
      9-16 Players: 4 Swiss Rounds, Top 4 Cut
      17-32 Players: 5 Swiss Rounds, Top 8 Cut
      33-64 Players: 6 Swiss Rounds, Top 8 Cut
      65-128 Players: 7 Swiss Rounds, Top 8 Cut
      129-226 Players: 8 Swiss Rounds, Top 8 Cut
      227-256 Players: 8 Swiss Rounds, Top 16 Cut
      · Players are restricted on what Pokémon can be used. Please check pokemon.com for the latest video game requirements.
      Day 2:
      · Top Cut: Determined by attendance, see above chart. Top Cut will be Single Elimination Finals, run as best-of-three matches, approx. 15 minutes PER GAME.
      RAFFLES: Saturday (between 5pm -6pm, subject to change): You can check back on Sunday to see if you won!
      To be announced!
      Everyone who registers for the main event will get a Raffle Ticket. You can earn extra Raffle tickets thru the Side Events and also earn an extra ticket for every $30 spent in one transaction per Vendor at the tables in the main event area. (For example: If you spend $60 at the Vendor table, you would get 2 Raffle tickets, you cannot combine different vendor purchases). You must be present to win!
      Side Events
      Saturday starts at NOON Sunday starts at 8:30am
      All players will get a Raffle ticket for each event you play on Saturday. Prizes will be posted at the event.
      Most side events require an entry fee.
      Prize wall tickets will be awarded for each side event (excluding the LC and PC on Sunday).
      The prize wall closes on Sunday at 4 p.m. Prizes must be redeemed by that time (subject to change).
      See the side events area at the Arizona Regional Championships for more details.
      ALL DAY - 8 player tournaments – Standard VG Doubles or Singles - $5.00 entry
      ALL DAY - 8 player tournaments - Junior Division Only (doubles or singles) – Free (maximum of 2 free entries)
      Saturday- Time: TBA Little Cup singles - $10
      Saturday- Time: TBA Monotype doubles - $10
      Format details can be found here: http://www.pokemon.com/…/pl…/worlds/2016/side-events-format/
      Sunday -- Premier Challenge - –$10 entry (Championship points are the prizes for this event).
      Registration starts: 9am Registration ends: 10am
      Saturday -ALL DAY - Play all day (no limit) with the purchase of a $5 wristband. Battle your friends, practice and have fun!!
      ----------------Please visit the POKKEN Sign up table for more information-----------------
      Sunday - 8:30am - Noon - Warm ups $5/Free if you purchased a Saturday wristband.
                      8:30am - Noon - Registration for the Pokken Tournament
                                  Entry Fee: $10 + Venue Fee: $5
                    12:30pm POKKEN TOURNAMENT
      Details: Double Elimination, visit the Pokken Sign up table for more information
      Prizes: TBA at the event
      There will be a SPECIAL TEAM SPECIFIC ITEM given to all players who sign up to compete in the Pokemon GO events. (supplies are limited)
      Entry fee: $6 per person per event below. Sign up for one or both.
      Saturday and Sunday: Sign up anytime after 8:30am and choose which event you want to compete.
      Basic - Sign up, pay the Entry fee, then come back to the Sign up table when your ready to start playing (no later than 3pm Saturday). We will log in your current Collector/Battle Girl numbers. You will play for 3 hours. We will note your Start time and the time you need to Check back in. (Saturday sign up ends at 3pm. Sunday sign up ends at Noon).
      You will be competing in these two categories. Try to win 1 or both!
      Collector - Increased # Captured Pokemon
      Battle Girl - Increased # Gym battles won
      Prizes* for each category:
      1st - $10 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Voucher.
      2nd - $10 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Voucher.
      Saturday: Basic winners will be announced shortly after 6pm. You may check on Sunday to see if your a winner.
      Sunday: Basic winners will be announced shortly after 3pm. You must be present to pick up your prize.
      Evolved - Sign up anytime after 8:30am. We will log in your current Jogger/Breeder numbers and you have until Noon on Sunday to check back in. Yes, this means if you sign up on Saturday you have alot more time to win in these categories below. Yes you are accumulating the information both Saturday and Sunday.
      You will be competing in these two categories. Try to win 1 or both!
      Jogger - Increased # steps walked
      Breeder - Increased # hatched eggs.
      Prizes* for each category:
      1st - $20 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Gift Card/Voucher.
      2nd - $20 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Gift Card/Voucher.
      3rd - $10 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Gift Card/Voucher.
      4th - $10 Google, ITunes or Regionals Vendor Gift Card/Voucher.
      Sunday: Evolved winners will be announced shortly after Noon. You must be present to pick up your prize.
      * There is a limited number of Google and ITunes cards available. Regional Vendor Gift vouchers will be given out as an choice or when all other cards are depleted.
      Sunday October 2nd
      Main event: TOP CUT TCG & TOP CUT VG
      (Side events will be going on ALL DAY too!)
      Where: Phoenix Convention Center, (South Building), 100 N 3rd St. Phoenix, AZ 85004
      All TCG and VG TOP CUT players CHECK IN: 8am
      (more details to follow)
      Side Events start at 8:30am

      Transportation: The Metro Light Rail stops at the entrance to the South Building of the Phoenix Convention Center. An all Day pass is only $4 per person and can be purchased at any station. ($2 All Day Pass for Youths age 6-18, Children under 5 years old are Free).
      Sky harbor airport now has a “Sky Train” which connects to The Metro Light Rail too. There are many hotels along the entire route of The Metro Light Rail.
      There are many hotels around the venue and some have lower rates. We could not secure a Pokemon rate. However, If you are willing to stay uptown alittle bit there is a Ramada Inn one block from the Metro Light Rail stop for Osborne Rd. Alot of Pokemon players will be staying here, when you book it online, make sure you become a Wyndham reward member before you book and the room rate will drop in price. Very reasonable.
      There will be a food vendor inside our Main event hall. There are places to eat outside surrounding the building but they will most likey be extremely busy. Half –block in the North Building of the Convention Center there is a food court. You can also order Postmates (a food delivery service) www.postmates.com and use this code (UR4Q) to get a discount!
      Vendors: (More Vendors will be announced in next weeks email)
      Cradilicious: The latest Pokémon Center plushies, keychains, pens, notebooks, earrings, Japanese deck boxes and sleeves, Pokémon Japanese packs, World Championship 2015 plushies and selling singles (English and Japanese). They will also take bulk cards in exchange for Cradilicious credit. Check out our Facebook page for pictures of the current items.
      Amazing Discoveries: Buying and Selling single cards (Tournament Legal ONLY-BLW to current), also buying Bulk commons & uncommons @ $4.00 Cash For 1000 Cards AND they must be mint and in a Card box. They will also offer a 25% trade over cash for any of the Tournament Legal Singles. They will not be buying any older cards.
      Samurai Comics: They will have a great selection of gaming accessories such as Dice, Deck Protectors and Deck boxes! Also, Pop! Vinyl figures, comic books, mystery boxes, Marvel merchandise, Pokemon plushies, posters, figures and more!
      ****I hope you will all join us for this memorable occasion. This is our 4th TCG & VG Regional Championships held in Phoenix, Arizona. Another epic event with awesome prizes.
      Join the crowd of elite Pokémon players who strive to be the very best like no one ever was!
      Someone will be the winner and it could be your destiny!
      Check us out on: https://www.facebook.com/AZRegionals/
      Patricia McCann
      ----Premier Tournament Organizer
    • By fuadorko
      I'm in San Jose atm. Thinking about going to the Phoenix regionals, but I don't want to go alone. Anyone want to carpool and roompool to go to Phoenix on Sep30-Oct2?
    • By Yeti Gaming
      We are excited to announce that registration for the Orlando Regionals is OPEN!   Players must Register and pay online prior to the event. We will have late and at the door registration as space permits.   Please share far and wide!   We are excited about this event and can't wait to see you all! Denise & Vince Ronae & Randy   http://www.poke-regionals.com/registration.html
    • By Yeti Gaming
      Hi Everyone!
      We are excited to announce that we will be hosting 2 Pokemon VGC Regional Championships this year!!!
      Orlando, Florida- October 15-16, 2016 & Collinsville Il (St. Louis, MO metro area)- March 4-5, 2017
      While we are waiting on some final info from The Pokemon Company, we do know that Prize Support has been increased dramatically!
      Information about the Orlando Regional Championships can be found at http://www.poke-regionals.com/.  
      We will have the Main Tournament and Side Events all weekend! Our Side event Prizing will be set up similar to Nationals and Worlds with the Prize Wall, which will include Pokemon Plush and other items for our VGC Players!
      Online Registration links will be live soon. Entry is $30.00 for Masters. $20.00 for Seniors and Juniors. This year we also have different levels of Registration, $50.00 & $100.00 for Masters. These Level 2 and Level 3 Registration Levels come with additional goodies such as Event Tickets.
      All Players will receive one of 4 hats upon entry: Motres, Articuno, Zapdos or Zygarde. Level 3 Registration allows players to select their hat of choice plus a Pokemon Playmat!
      LOCATION: DoubleTree by Hilton at the Entrance to Universal Orlando-Click for Location Info and Area Hotel  WHEN: October 15-16, 2016 PRIZES: TBA! Check out http://www.pokemon.com/us/pokemon-news/big-play-pokemon-changes-on-the-way-for-2017/ for TPCi announcement on the upcoming season! REGISTRATION: ALL players must register online!  Regular Registration CLOSES October 9, 2016 at 11:59 pm est. Late Registration will have an increase of $10.00 and will continue as long as their is space available.   
      Follow us on Facebook & Twitter   to stay up to date on all the Upcoming Announcements!!
      Thanks again for joining us at another Great Pokemon Season!
      Denise Krekeler
  • Blog Entries